Skip over navigation

Early death risks higher for manual workers

Related content: Early death risks higher for manual workers

Report abuse


2.
Nigel Dupree
Member - 1531 posts
27 Aug 2010 10:04AM

Wha-hey Andrew - Cause and effect missing and for sure needs a little more back engineering in chain of causation as health stressors maybe different and one thing for sure we are all gonna die just a question of when and how not if.


1.
Andrew Auty
Member - 110 posts
27 Aug 2010 12:29AM

Before any conclusions can be drawn about health and safety at work there needs to be some report of causes of death and then mechanisms linking those causes to work. The story presented here omits both steps and uses the HSE spokesperson statement as if all the pieces were present in the jigsaw. They are not. Perhaps the logical development was edited out?

Comparison of routine manual workers with workers who are in every way identical but don't do routine manual work would be more scientific. Comparison with managers is just a publicity stunt.



Add a comment


Send me an email-alert when someone comments in this discussion:

Please remember that your name and comment will be visible to all users of the Network, and that we may edit or remove comments without notice. Terms and conditions