Skip over navigation

Disability ruling applied in landmark employment case

Related content: Disability ruling applied in landmark employment case


3.
Carole Simmons
Member - 607 posts
17 Feb 2009 1:04AM

Mike if everyone thought like you we would have no need for landmark employment cases!!

Having been through a disability discrimination tribunal recently I can asure you it is not a pleasant experiance because you are somehow made to feel that it is you that is the guilty party and have done something wrong!

I dont know yet if justice has been served but what I do know is that the bigger the company the swankier the lawyer, money buys clever lawyers that twist things including "their" version of the law! We'll see but I think this decision is a one for common sense just as the recent House of Lords one was not!


2.
ruth malkin
Member - 100 posts
16 Feb 2009 11:56AM

I'll let you know my opinion on this after I get treated with 'unfair favour'. I have been disabled since birth and I am in my forties now and it hasn't happened yet...


1.
Mike Pinsent
Member - 29 posts
13 Feb 2009 10:36AM

"The correct approach is now to compare the way the disabled person has been treated to the way that a non-disabled person in the same situation would have been treated. "

This seems wise and common sense - and in fact to do otherwise is discriminatory - even if on the surface it looked like being more favourable to the disabled person. They need understanding and the same respect as others - patronising them with 'unfair favour' should be a thing of the past. Fair treatment of all must be the primary aim: equality can only be truly meaningful if we are comparing like with like - which is not always easy.


Add a comment


Send me an email-alert when someone comments in this discussion:

Please remember that your name and comment will be visible to all users of the Network, and that we may edit or remove comments without notice. Terms and conditions