Workplace Law Network The membership site for UK employers and managers, specialising in employment law, health and safety and premises management
10th Anniversary Facilities Management Legal Update Conference & Gala Dinner
PPA awards Workplace Law business website of the year (paid for)
  • NETWORK
  • TRAINING
  • CONSULTING
  • BOOKSHOP
  • HOME
    • ABOUT MEMBERSHIP
    • ABOUT US
  • LATEST
    • NEWS
    • CASES
    • BRIEFINGS
    • AUDIO
    • EBULLETINS
    • WHAT THE PAPERS SAY
    • NETWORK NEWS
  • INFO CENTRE
    • WHITE PAPERS
    • FACTSHEETS
    • MAGAZINE
    • POLICIES & PROCEDURES
    • SPECIAL REPORTS
    • GUIDES
    • REGULATION FINDER
  • ADVICE CENTRE
    • ONLINE ADVICE
    • TELEPHONE ADVICE
  • FORUMS & GROUPS
    • FORUMS
    • GROUPS
  • MEMBERSHIP
    • MY PROFILE
    • SPECIAL OFFERS
    • MEMBERSHIP STATUS
  • SHOP
  • CONTACT
  • LOG IN
  • or Register now
  • You are here:
  • Network
  • Forums & Groups
  • Forums
  • Opinion

HSE Raises Stakes on Driver Safety

This discussion is about the news HSE Raises Stakes on Driver Safety


Not rated yet
Rate this!
6 Aug 2002 10:55AM

Anonymous

Whilst anything that reduces accidents must be welcome how come that only mobiles are being concentrated on?
What is the difference between a good hands free system and an in vehicle conversation between driver and passengers? What about the use of two way radio systems? Will single occupied emergency vehicle be banned from using their equipment when on the move?
I consider drivers who smoke more of a hazard than a handsfree mobile phone system because they have to find the packet and get the cigarete out, have a heat source (lighter, match etc) within the vehicle and then proceed to throw the ash and lit cigarette ends out of the window.
It appears to be 'lets latch on to the latest something' and, as usual when it affects motoring, little work appears to have been put into thinking all the ramifications through.



Not rated yet
Rate this!
8 Aug 2002 11:35PM

Anonymous

I totally agree about the risk of smoking while driving. The smoker has to apply the lighter to the end of the cigarette - locating the end of the cigarette 4 inches from their face - at night creating a light source in the cabin of the vehicle. I have also been with smokers driving who drop the lighted cigarette and frantically try to find it before it burns them their clothing or the seat of the car. This practice is far more dangerous.
However it is essential that use of handheld mobiles in vehicles must be stopped - as a high mileage vehicle user I have lost count of the potential collisons caused by drivers with the handset held to their ears.



Not rated yet
Rate this!
9 Aug 2002 11:19AM

Anonymous

I agree with all the comments made about smoking whilst driving but where do you stop? We have all seen drivers eating and drinking whilst driving, there are laws in force that the Police can use to bring prosecutions but for some reason they are not used unless a serious RTA occurs.
What about the emergency services,in particular the Police? They use radios whilst driving.
We must get away from making knee jerk laws, the whole issue of safe driving must be made the subject of a thorough investigation by a Government backed panel of experts.
I have been a magistrate for 5 years and have never been involved with a case where a driver has been prosecuted for not being in full control of his vehicle for any of the reasons mentioned. It's simply a very grey area.



Not rated yet
Rate this!
19 Aug 2002 4:34PM

Anonymous

The difference between holding a conversation with a passenger and holding one on a mobile phone, is that the passenger can see situations developing and knows when to avoid taking the driver's attention. The mobile caller treats the conversation as if the driver is at his desk and expects normal concentration levels. The driver cannot achieve this without losing concentration on the road. Safe driving is not a part time job which can be carried out at the same time as other activities.



Not rated yet
Rate this!
18 Oct 2002 4:55PM

Anonymous

I agree with peter's comment about driving not being a part time job. However the driver, on her/his handsfree phone, should advise any caller that s/he is driving, at the outset.
Like almost everything, commonsense must be the order of the day rather in the first instance than, as said above, knee jerk legislation.



Not rated yet
Rate this!
17 Jun 2003 11:04PM

Anonymous

Whilst everybody else is concerned about the use of mobile phones, how many have looked at drinking and eating whislt driving. Where are your eyes when you have a can or bottle of drink at your lips? Especially when you are at the last few drops. Park up and have a drink and look where your eyes are! What happens if you spill it. I am a fleet trainer, nobody is perfect, the only perfecr driver will not have a radio, mobile phone, drink or a bag of crisps in his car, anybody managed to eat a bag of crips whilst driving and keep both hands on the wheel and he/she does not smoke. Why do they put radios/cd players, cigarette lighters and vanity mirrors in cars?





Send me an email-alert when someone comments in this discussion:

YesNo

Please remember that your name and comment will be visible to all users of the Network, and that we may edit or remove comments without notice. Terms and conditions



Disclaimer

The forums are designed as a discussion area for employers and managers to exchange ideas and information, or to ask and answer questions posed by other members of the Workplace Law Network.

Please don't abuse the forums by asking questions about personal issues or by overtly promoting commercial goods and services.

We impose upon all participants the obligation to comply with our terms and conditions» but cannot guarantee that all participants will do so.

Please note that the Workplace Law Network is not able to assert editorial control or ensure moderation over the forum section of the site, and you participate at your own risk.



Breathe commercial interiors
NEBOSH National General Certificate
Upload your image
View my:
  • Profile
  • Downloads
  • Scrapbook
  • Order history

My messages0 (0)Shop

  • Premium membership trial

    7 days instant access to membership with no strings attached.

  • 1 minute tour

    See what the Network has to offer in just 60 seconds.

  • Membership quotamator

    Build your own membership quote online!

  • Recommend membership
  • Print friendly version

AWARDS

  • ppa logo
  • aop logo
  • Absence
  • Accidents at work
  • Alcohol/drugs
  • Asbestos
  • Building regulations
  • Bullying/harassment
  • Business continuity
  • Business regulation
  • Buying and selling property
  • Catering
  • CCTV & employee monitoring
  • Confined spaces
  • Construction
  • Consultation
  • Contract workers
  • Contracts, employment
  • Contracts, facilities management
  • Corporate killing
  • Data protection
  • Directors' responsibilities
  • Disability
  • Disciplinary, Grievance, Dismissal
  • Discrimination
  • Display screen equipment
  • Driving at work
  • Electrical safety
  • Energy management
  • Environment management
  • Fire safety
  • First aid
  • Fleet management
  • Flexible working
  • Fuel storage
  • Gas safety
  • Hazardous substances
  • Health and safety
  • Health, surveillance
  • Height, working at
  • Holidays
  • Homeworking
  • Human resources
  • Human rights
  • Insurance
  • Intellectual property
  • Internet and email
  • Landlord and tenant
  • Legionella
  • Lighting
  • Lone working
  • Manual handling
  • Maternity, paternity, adoption
  • Minimum wage
  • Money laundering
  • Mothers, new and expectant
  • Nebosh Certificate
  • Noise
  • Outsourcing
  • Parking
  • Pensions and benefits
  • Permits to work
  • Personal protective equipment
  • Pest control
  • Planning procedures
  • Pollution
  • Property management
  • Radiation
  • Rates and revaluation
  • Recruitment and selection
  • Redundancy
  • Security
  • Signage
  • Smoking
  • Stress
  • Trade unions
  • TUPE
  • Vehicles
  • Ventilation, temperature
  • Violence
  • Waste management
  • Welfare facilities
  • Whistleblowing
  • Work equipment
  • Working time
  • About us
  • Privacy policy
  • Contact us
  • Terms and conditions
  • Accessibility
  • Careers
  • Membership
  • Sitemap
  • NEBOSH certificate
Promotion code: None

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional

© Copyright Workplace Law Group Ltd 1995-2008